Civilization Games Ranked

Civilization 4 is the best Civilization game by our rule, at 93.0 from its 94 on Metacritic and its 92% on Steam, read Nov 15, 2026. Civilization 5 is half a point behind, Civilization 7 is sixth at 65.0, and we think Civilization 4 with Beyond the Sword is the best of all.

Civilization 4 is the best Civilization game by our rule: it scores 93.0, the average of its 94 on Metacritic and the 92% of its Steam reviews that are positive, both read on Nov 15, 2026. We rate Civilization 4 S tier, and we think its Beyond the Sword expansion makes it the best Civilization of all, 19 years after that expansion came out. Civilization 5 is half a point behind at 92.5. The newest game, Civilization 7, is sixth of seven at 65.0, C tier, from 79 and 51%. The original 1991 game is last only because no published score exists to rank it on.

We think Civilization 7 stays sixth on this list through 2027: its all-time Steam share will still be under 60% after the Earthrise expansion is out, because the 461 reviews of the last 30 days are also 51% positive, six months after the Test of Time update let players keep one civilization for a whole game.

Confidence: Likely. Check by: Dec 2027.

How we rate

Each game's score is the average of two halves, both read on Nov 15, 2026 and linked in the table:

  • Critics: the Metacritic Metascore of the PC version.
  • Players: the share of Steam user reviews that are positive, all time, as Steam's store page shows it to an English-language visitor.

Two games are not sold on Steam, and the table labels them. Civilization 2 has a Metascore, so its player half is Metacritic's user score times ten. The 1991 Civilization has neither a Metascore nor a user score (Metacritic's page says critic reviews "are not available"), so the rule cannot score it, and it takes last place and D tier by default.

Tiers: S 93 or more, A 90 to 92.9, B 85 to 89.9, C 65 to 84.9, D under 65 or unscored. The bands are narrow at the top because five of the six scored games sit within 6.5 points of each other. For Civilization 4 we score the base game (Steam app 3900), not the expansion; what that choice changes is in our own view below.

All seven games, best first

Rank Tier Play Game Critics Players Score
1 S Civilization 4 (2005) 94 92% 93.0
Both halves agree: the top critic score in the series, shared with Civilization 2, and 92% of 1,961 Steam reviews 21 years on.
2 A Civilization 5 (2010) 90 95% 92.5
The best player half of all, 95% of 78,968 Steam reviews, leaves it half a point from first.
3 A Civilization 3 (2001) 90 91% 90.5
Critics and players are a point apart, 90 and 91% of 4,140 reviews of the Complete edition.
4 B Civilization 2 (1996) 94 85 (not on Steam: Metacritic user score 8.5) 89.5
It shares the top critic score, but from 7 reviews, and its player half comes from 538 Metacritic ratings, which run lower than Steam's.
5 B Civilization 6 (2016) 88 85% 86.5
The most reviewed game here, 108,177 on Steam, with the lowest score of the five older games that have one.
6 C Civilization 7 (2025) 79 51% 65.0
The lowest critic score in the series and a player half of 51% of 30,153 reviews, the widest gap between critics and players on the list.
7 D Civilization (1991) none none (not on Steam) Unscored
Metacritic has no critic or user score for it and no store we checked sells it, so the rule has nothing to count.

The Play column is one video per game from its first second: the opening of a Civilization 4 game by Sullla, the official launch trailers of Civilization 5, 6 and 7 from the Sid Meier's Civilization channel, a Civilization 3 game on its hardest difficulty and a Civilization 2 video by Suede, and LGR's review of the 1991 game. The lead clip is IGN's short history of the series. The tiers come out S 1, A 2, B 2, C 1, D 1.

The gap between critics and players. Subtract the player half from the critic half and the games fall into two groups. Civilization 5 and Civilization 3 are the two that players rate higher than critics did, by 5 points and by 1; Civilization 4 and 6 lose 2 and 3 points. Civilization 7 loses 28. Its Metascore of 79 from 101 reviews would put it only 9 points under Civilization 6, and it is the players' half that drops it a whole tier.

How close the top is. Civilization 4 leads Civilization 5 by 0.5. One more point on Civilization 5's Metascore, or two fewer points on Civilization 4's Steam share, would swap them. We would not read much into the order of the top two by the rule alone, which is why the next section says what we think and why.

Our view: Civilization 4 with Beyond the Sword is the best of all

This part is opinion, and it is ours. Civpedia's editors still play Civilization 4: Beyond the Sword, and we think it is the best Civilization game, on its gameplay and on its challenge:

  • The AI can still beat you. On Emperor and above, the computer players in Beyond the Sword expand, tech and attack well enough that a win has to be earned. We think no later game in the series puts up the same fight without leaning as hard on bonuses.
  • Stacks and collateral damage. Armies move as stacks, and siege weapons damage everything in the tile they hit. We think that makes war a question of what you built and when, and it lets the AI fight competently, which one unit per tile never managed.
  • Civics, religion and the slider. Civics you mix freely, religions that shape who your friends are, and a slider that splits your commerce between research, gold, culture and espionage. We think every one of those decisions stays open for the whole game.
  • The mods. Realism Invictus, Fall from Heaven 2 and Caveman2Cosmos are whole games built on Beyond the Sword, and they are a large part of why people still play it. Our Civilization 4 viki covers the expansion and its mods in depth.

Steam's own counts back the claim that it is still played: on Nov 15, 2026 more than twice as many people were in Beyond the Sword as in the base game, and the figures are on Civilization Steam Player Counts.

Where our view and the rule differ

  1. The rule ranks the base game; we mean the expansion. Scored alone, Beyond the Sword gets 86 from critics and 96% from 2,911 Steam reviews, an average of 91.0. That would be third, behind the base game and Civilization 5. Critics score expansions lower than the games they extend (Brave New World got 85, Gathering Storm 80), and we think the players' 96%, the highest share on this page, is the better guide here.
  2. Civilization 1 is not a D game. It is last because nothing published scores it. On influence it is the most important game on the list, and we would place it at B: a game to respect and read about on Civilization 1 more than one to play in 2026, since no store sells it.
  3. Civilization 2 at fourth rests on the thinnest evidence. Seven critic reviews and a user score from a site whose users rate every Civilization lower than Steam's do (Civilization 4 gets 8.4 there). With a Steam page it would probably sit in A. We leave it where the rule puts it.
  4. We agree with the rule on Civilization 7, for now. C is fair for a game half of its players do not recommend. We think it is a better game since the Test of Time update of May 19, 2026 than its all-time share says, and the reviews of the last 30 days have not moved yet.

Who should play something else

We think Civilization 4 is the best, and it is not the best for everyone.

  • Play Civilization 5 if you want tactical combat on hexes with one unit per tile, city-states, and the culture and ideology game of Brave New World. It has the highest player score here, and we think it is the easiest of the older games to recommend to someone new. The two are set side by side on Civilization 4 vs Civilization 5.
  • Play Civilization 6 if you want the most played Civilization today, districts that spread your cities across the map, and versions on Switch, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One.
  • Play Civilization 7 if you want the game Firaxis is still changing: a free fourth Age and the Earthrise expansion are both planned for 2027, and Civilization 7 vs Civilization 6 says which of the two newest games we would buy.
  • Play Civilization 3 if you want the series at its simplest with borders and culture in place. It costs about a dollar, and our Civilization 3 viki is the place to start.

The ranking we disagree with: Kotaku's

Kotaku's ranking by Luke Plunkett (Mar 31, 2020) covers the six games that existed then and puts them, best first: Civilization 5, Civilization 4, Civilization 6, Civilization 3, Civilization 1, Civilization 2.

We disagree with it in two places.

  • Civilization 5 over Civilization 4. Kotaku writes that Civilization 4 "took everything about the series' original vision" and "pretty much perfected it", then puts Civilization 5 first for removing "tedious relics": the square grid and unit stacking. We think stacking with collateral damage is the better war game, and our rule, by half a point, sides with us. Even Civilization 5's own designers argued about it: its expansion lead Ed Beach told PC Gamer in 2013 that "unit stacking can be a problem in Civ V", meaning the crowding that one unit per tile causes.
  • Civilization 2 last. Kotaku says there is "very little" about it "that you can recommend that isn't done better elsewhere". Critics of its day gave it 94, level with Civilization 4, and our rule has it fourth even with a handicap on its player half.

Where we agree: Kotaku has Civilization 6 below both Civilization 4 and 5, and so does the rule. Its list predates Civilization 7.

Sources

Moments

Civilization: How Sid Meier Built a Strategy Game Empire - IGN Game Changers

IGN

  1. Civilization 4 is the best Civilization game by our rule: it scores 93.0, the average of its 94 on Metacritic and the…

Civ4: The Madness of King Ramesses, Part One

Sullla YouTube Channel

  1. Civilization 4 (2005) · 94 · 92% · 93.0

Sid Meier's Civilization V Launch Trailer

Sid Meier's Civilization

  1. Civilization 5 (2010) · 90 · 95% · 92.5

Civ 3's Hardest Difficulty Done Right

Suede

  1. Civilization 3 (2001) · 90 · 91% · 90.5

Civ 2 will RUIN you (in the best way)

Suede

  1. Civilization 2 (1996) · 94 · 85 (not on Steam: Metacritic user score 8.5) · 89.5

CIVILIZATION VI Launch Trailer

Sid Meier's Civilization

  1. Civilization 6 (2016) · 88 · 85% · 86.5

Sid Meier's Civilization VII - Official Launch Trailer

Sid Meier's Civilization

  1. Civilization 7 (2025) · 79 · 51% · 65.0

LGR - Sid Meier's Civilization - DOS PC Game Review

LGR

  1. Civilization (1991) · none · none (not on Steam) · Unscored

See also

About this page

Last updated Nov 15, 2026 by the Vi.ki team. Page text CC BY-SA 4.0.

Edit History

Hotkeys

/
Jump to the search box
? or Ctrl + /
Open this list
Esc
Close this list, the photo viewer, or the account menu

Video

Space or K
Play or pause
← →
Back or forward 5 seconds
J L
Back or forward 10 seconds
0 to 9
Go to 0% to 90% of the video
, .
Previous or next frame, while paused
M
Mute or unmute
C
Captions on or off
F
Full screen on or off
A D
Previous or next moment

Photo viewer

← → or A D
Previous or next photo
↑ ↓ or W S
Previous or next photo
Home End
First or last photo
I
Show or hide the photo's info
Z
Clickless on or off: a pointer over a thumbnail shows it
N
Compare with the last photo: back to the one shown before this, and N again comes back
Q
Move the thumbnails to the next edge: top, bottom, left and round
, or Ctrl + ,
Open or close the viewer's settings
V
Clickless pan: a zoomed photo follows the pointer, rather than being dragged
Shift
Browse on or off
B
Show or hide the button bar
T
Show or hide the thumbnails
1
100% zoom on or off
0
Rate the photo as no opinion; again takes the answer back
+ -
Rate the photo a step higher or lower
F
Full screen: the photo alone. F again puts everything back.
Back to top