Civilization 4 vs Civilization 5

We think Civilization 4: Beyond the Sword is the better game and Civilization 5 the better place to find other players. On Nov 15, 2026 Civilization 5 had 18,916 players on Steam to Beyond the Sword's 2,172, and all of Civilization 4 cost $5.99 on sale against $16.80 for all of Civilization 5.

We still play Civilization 4: Beyond the Sword, and we think it is a better game than Civilization 5. On Nov 15, 2026 that is a minority position by one measure and a tie by another. At 11:03 PM Dubai time Steam counted 18,916 people in Civilization 5 and 2,172 in Beyond the Sword, plus 866 in the base game: 8.7 players in the 2010 game for each one in the 2007 expansion. But the people who bought them rate them almost the same, 96% positive for Beyond the Sword and 95% for Civilization 5. By our rule for the series (the average of the PC Metascore and the Steam review share, with Civilization 4 scored on its base game) Civilization 4 is S tier at 93.0 and Civilization 5 A tier at 92.5, half a point apart. Until Nov 19 the whole of Civilization 4 is $5.99 on Steam and the whole of Civilization 5 is $16.80. Play Civilization 4 for the opponent and the economy. Play Civilization 5 for hexes, tactical battles and company.

We think Civilization 4: The Complete Edition will be back at $5.99 or less on Steam during the winter sale, because it is at that price in the middle of November, 80% off in a promotion that also covers Civilization 3 and Civilization 5 today.

Confidence: Likely. Check by: Jan 2027.

How we rate, and where we part from the score

Every numbered Civilization game gets one score, the average of its PC Metascore and the share of its English-language Steam reviews that are positive, read Nov 15, 2026. Civilization 4 is scored on its base game: 94 on Metacritic and 92% on Steam average 93.0, S tier. Civilization 5 has 90 and 95%, which average 92.5, A tier, half a point under the S line of 93. The full ranking of the seven games is on Civilization Games Ranked.

Beyond the Sword's 96% rests on 2,911 reviews and Civilization 5's 95% on 78,968, 27 times as many. The rule gives it to Civilization 4 by half a point, the critics by four points, and the crowd, counted by who is playing tonight, gives it to Civilization 5 by a wide margin. Our view agrees with the rule and the critics, and the rest of this page says why.

The differences

Civilization 4 here means the game with Warlords and Beyond the Sword, which is what the Complete Edition installs. Civilization 5 means the game with Gods and Kings and Brave New World.

Feature Civilization 4 Civilization 5
Released Oct 25, 2005; Beyond the Sword Jul 24, 2007 Sep 21, 2010; Brave New World 2013
Lead designer Soren Johnson Jon Shafer; Ed Beach for both expansions
Map grid Squares, viewed straight on "like a chessboard" Hexes
Units per tile Any number One military unit
The counter to a big army Collateral damage from catapults, cannons and artillery Terrain and positioning
Ranged combat Siege units bombard city defenses; battles are unit against unit Ranged units fire from behind the front line; cities shoot back
Economy One commerce pool, split by a slider between research and gold No slider; each yield is collected on its own
What limits expansion City maintenance, rising with the number of cities and distance from the capital One happiness score for the whole empire
Government Civics in five categories, changed at will at the price of anarchy Social policies, adopted one by one and kept
Religion Seven religions in the base game Added by Gods and Kings in 2012
Espionage Spy units; Great Spies in Beyond the Sword Added by Gods and Kings in 2012
Vassal states Yes, from Warlords No
Technology trading Yes Research agreements
City-states No Yes, new in this game
Corporations and random events Beyond the Sword No
Trade routes, World Congress, ideologies No Brave New World
Ways to win Six: Conquest, Cultural, Diplomatic, Domination, Space Race, Time Science, culture, diplomacy, conquest
Civilizations 18 at launch, 34 with both expansions 18 at launch, 43 with everything
The computer opponent Discounts on units, buildings and research as difficulty rises Its designer called combat AI one of the biggest problems of one unit per tile
Multiplayer Designed as a multiplayer game first; Steam lists Beyond the Sword as single-player today Steam lists multiplayer
Mods XML, Python, World Builder and a game and AI SDK Steam Workshop and a modding SDK
On Steam for Windows, Mac Windows, Mac, Linux

Read on Nov 15, 2026: 2K's pages for Civilization IV and Civilization V for expansions, rosters, victories, vassals, city-states and research agreements; the Civilization 4 manual for the slider, anarchy, maintenance, religions, technology trading and mod tools; Jon Shafer's 2013 essay for the missing slider, global happiness and policies; the two Steam pages for platforms and features. Ed Beach gave the 34 and 43 himself, telling PC Gamer in 2013 that "there are now 43 civs in the game, and the most any Civ has had up until now was 34."

Stacks of doom against one unit per tile

The stack was not an oversight in Civilization 4. Soren Johnson's afterword in the manual names the problem by its fan nickname, the Stack-of-Doom, and explains where it comes from: he had given every unit a counter (spearmen beat horsemen, archers hold hills), and "if every unit has a counter, the best strategy is simply to put all of your units in a giant stack", because the best defender always answers the attack. His fix was borrowed from the first Civilization, which killed every unit on a square when its defender lost. Civilization 4 uses "a lesser version": catapults, cannons and artillery damage many units in the stack they hit. In his words they are "the stack-killers, which creates a great tension between keeping units together for mutual defense and spreading units out to avoid collateral damage."

That tension is the game we like. A Civilization 4 war is a question of how much to commit to one square, what to send in first to soften it, and what to hold back for the counterattack. It is decided as much by what you built in the 30 turns before as by where you stand.

Jon Shafer wanted the opposite, a war decided on the map. His own essay of Feb 18, 2013 says one unit per tile was "very much inspired by the old wargame Panzer General" and that it "forced players to spread out their armies across the landscape". Then he lists the bill. "Every unit needed its own tile, and that meant the map filled up pretty quickly." To keep the map from filling he "slowed the rate of production, which in turn led to more waiting around for buckets to fill up." And: "One of the biggest challenges unearthed by 1UPT was writing a competent combat AI." His next game, he wrote, would allow stacks.

Two replies are worth setting beside that. Ed Beach, who led both Civilization 5 expansions, said in April 2013 that Shafer "was a little harsh on it" and that he was "still a big fan of one unit per tile", while agreeing that "we didn't quite hit it right with the initial release". And Johnson, writing about his own later game in 2021, did not defend stacks: he used one unit per tile himself, and argued that Civilization 5's trouble was too little room between cities and too little mobility for the number of units a long game produces.

So the two lead designers each came to doubt their own answer. We think Johnson's was still the better fit for this series, for the reason Shafer gave: Civilization's map is a strategic map, and a rule made for a wargame with a fixed set of units turns an empire of hundreds into a traffic problem that the computer opponent cannot solve. Our Civilization 4 site has the older comparison with press quotes for readers who want the reviewers' side.

The slider economy against separate yields

In Civilization 4 a city produces commerce, and one slider decides what share of the empire's commerce becomes research and what share becomes gold. Move it and the whole economy turns in a turn: research flat out while the treasury drains, then gold to pay for an upgrade wave before a war. Civilization 5 has no slider. Gold comes from one set of sources and science from another, and you change the balance by building different things over many turns.

Shafer's 2013 essay counts this among his regrets: without sliders players were, in his words, "permanently locked into their past economic choices." We think the slider is the least appreciated part of Civilization 4. It makes the economy something you steer, and it is the reason a Civilization 4 player can recover from a bad war and a Civilization 5 player often cannot.

City maintenance against global happiness

Both games needed a brake on founding cities without end. Johnson wrote that Civilization 3's corruption was "the number one complaint raised against the game", so he removed it and "made maintenance a flat cost per city that went up based on empire size." A new city costs gold until it grows into its keep. The brake is on your treasury, which the slider lets you manage, so the decision is yours: expand now and research slower, or the reverse.

Civilization 5 put the brake on happiness and made happiness one number for the whole empire. Shafer's verdict on his own system: "The problem was that happiness strongly encouraged you to stay small", and "it was virtually impossible to build the large, sprawling empires which had always been a feature in the series." Small empires became the sound way to play Civilization 5. We think this, more than hexes, is what makes the two games feel so different after 100 turns.

Civics against social policies

Civilization 4's civics replaced the fixed governments of the first three games with five categories you set independently, and you can change any of them later if you accept turns of anarchy. Civilization 5's social policies are bought one at a time and never given back. Shafer explained that he wanted an empire to feel like it was "slowly accumulating this identity over time", and then sided with the older game: "I now find the design of Civics more appealing, because of that capacity to make sudden and dramatic shifts."

The computer opponent

This is the heart of our view. Every Civilization helps its AI at high difficulty. Johnson described the method in a 2009 column: the series "gives out a progressive series of unit, building, and technology discounts for the AI as the levels increase". The difference between these two games is what the AI does with the help.

A stack is a simple thing for a program to use well: gather units, add siege, walk to the target. So Civilization 4's AI, given its discounts on Emperor or above, arrives with an army that can take cities, and Beyond the Sword's store page still advertises an AI that "relies more on smart play and less on handicap bonuses". Civilization 5's AI has to arrange a line of single units across hills and rivers, and its own designer called that one of the biggest problems the rule created. Metacritic's page for Civilization 5 records the result: its lower scores, down to 1UP's 50, name the AI among their complaints.

Shafer was just as direct about diplomacy. He wanted the leaders to act human, and wrote that they ended up "all crazy, and in the exact same way", which left a player asking "what's the point of investing in relationships at all?" Civilization 4's leaders have a state religion, favorite civics, allies and enemies, and Johnson's afterword says religion was added partly to give diplomacy "more logic". He also wrote that he "intentionally crippled the AI's ability to trade with one another", so the computer players would not swap technologies among themselves and leave the human behind.

We think that is why Civilization 4 is the harder game to beat fairly and the more satisfying one to win.

What Civilization 5 does better

  • Hexes. Johnson himself told PC Gamer that "we were a bit afraid of hexes at the time". On a hex map every neighboring tile is the same distance away, which a square grid with diagonal moves cannot offer.
  • Battles you can see. Archers on a hill behind a line of spearmen is a better image than a number on a stack. Beach is right that there is "so much more tactical maneuvering and positioning".
  • City-states. They give a peaceful player something to compete over, and Civilization 4 has nothing like them.
  • The late game after Brave New World. We think trade routes, tourism, ideologies and the World Congress give the last third of a Civilization 5 game more to do than Civilization 4's.
  • It is easier to get running and to play with others. It is on Windows, Mac and Linux, its Steam page lists multiplayer and the Workshop, and it has 8.7 times the players.
  • It is easier to learn. We think one unit per tile and a small empire ask less of a new player.

Prices and players today

Civilization 4 Civilization 5
Complete edition on Steam, Nov 15, 2026 $5.99 (80% off $29.99, ends Nov 19) $16.80 (bundle, on sale to Nov 19)
Cheapest way in Base game $3.99 (80% off $19.99) Base game $7.49 (75% off $29.99)
Civilizations in the complete edition 34 43
Price per civilization, complete 18 cents 39 cents
Steam players, 11:03 PM Dubai time 2,172 in Beyond the Sword, 866 in the base game 18,916
Steam reviews, English 96% of 2,911 95% of 78,968
Metacritic 94 90

The price per civilization is our division: $5.99 by 34 and $16.80 by 43. Steam counts Civilization 4's base game and each expansion as separate apps, so its 3,038 players across the two we read are still an undercount of everyone in the game, and Steam does not see copies bought elsewhere. Even so, Civilization 5 has six times that total.

Who should play which

Play Civilization 4: Beyond the Sword if you have won on the higher levels of a later game and want to lose again, if you like running an economy, if you want a war to be a matter of preparation, or if you want the mods. Fall from Heaven 2, Realism Invictus and Caveman2Cosmos exist because the game shipped with its own tools, and they are covered on our Civilization 4 mods page. The series page for the game is Civilization 4.

Play Civilization 5 if you want a game you can teach a friend in an evening, if you like placing units on terrain, if you want multiplayer that works through Steam, or if you want the largest pool of guides, mods and opponents of the two. Civilization 5 has the detail.

Play both. At $22.79 for the two complete editions this week, the cheapest way to settle the argument is to hold it yourself. Where the two sit among all seven games is on Civilization Games Compared.

Sources

Moments

Civilization 4 - BEGINNERS GUIDE - Part 1 - Getting Started

RazingHel

  1. We still play Civilization 4: Beyond the Sword, and we think it is a better game than Civilization 5. On Nov 15, 2026…

Civilization 4 - BEGINNERS GUIDE - Part 3 - Military & Conquest

RazingHel

  1. The stack was not an oversight in Civilization 4. Soren Johnson's afterword in the manual names the problem by its fan…

Civilization 4 - BEGINNERS GUIDE - Part 2 - Economy & Expansion

RazingHel

  1. In Civilization 4 a city produces commerce, and one slider decides what share of the empire's commerce becomes…

Sid Meier's Civilization V Launch Trailer

Sid Meier's Civilization

  1. This is the heart of our view. Every Civilization helps its AI at high difficulty. Johnson described the method in a…

See also

About this page

Last updated Nov 15, 2026 by the Vi.ki team. Page text CC BY-SA 4.0.

Edit History

Hotkeys

/
Jump to the search box
? or Ctrl + /
Open this list
Esc
Close this list, the photo viewer, or the account menu

Video

Space or K
Play or pause
← →
Back or forward 5 seconds
J L
Back or forward 10 seconds
0 to 9
Go to 0% to 90% of the video
, .
Previous or next frame, while paused
M
Mute or unmute
C
Captions on or off
F
Full screen on or off
A D
Previous or next moment

Photo viewer

← → or A D
Previous or next photo
↑ ↓ or W S
Previous or next photo
Home End
First or last photo
I
Show or hide the photo's info
Z
Clickless on or off: a pointer over a thumbnail shows it
N
Compare with the last photo: back to the one shown before this, and N again comes back
Q
Move the thumbnails to the next edge: top, bottom, left and round
, or Ctrl + ,
Open or close the viewer's settings
V
Clickless pan: a zoomed photo follows the pointer, rather than being dragged
Shift
Browse on or off
B
Show or hide the button bar
T
Show or hide the thumbnails
1
100% zoom on or off
0
Rate the photo as no opinion; again takes the answer back
+ -
Rate the photo a step higher or lower
F
Full screen: the photo alone. F again puts everything back.
Back to top